Goose Creek quakers: the audacity of peace and social justice

marble carved male head with beard
Pausanias (AD 110-C 180) was a Greek geographer, traveler and author. Stock photo.

Pausanias (AD 110- C 180) was a Greek geographer and author of travel books which included his observations about people and places. There is a well-known quote from Pausanias: “Audacity combined with weakness should be called madness.”

It is worth reflecting on this idea when studying the actions of 19th century southern Quakers, such as those of Goose Creek meeting who acted against their own legal, social and financial interests in the decades leading up to Civil War. They were pacifist, refusing to fight in wars. They publically spoke and acted against slavery. Were these actions “audacious”? I’d say yes. In early American history, Quakers were fined by courts and even imprisoned for not enlisting to fight in wars. (Some Quaker men bowed to social pressure or personal belief and did enlist in America’s conflicts, including the Civil War. Their actions, however, drew a Quaker response. If not discontinued, military participation resulted in religious disownment.)

Quaker anti-slavery beliefs were divisive, particularly in southern states, such as Virginia. Time and again certain members of the Goose Creek Meeting community took great risks in their abolitionist efforts. Think of William Tate, shot at as he rode through Rappahannock county one dark night in 1845. Or Francis Ray, the young teacher threatened with being tarred and feathered in 1856, simply for voicing anti-slavery views. Samuel M. Janney, arrested for repeatedly publishing anti-slavery articles in Southern newspapers.

19th century American racist cartoon
1856 racist political cartoon showing President Millard Fillmore as a weak “goose.” James Buchanan would go on to win the 1856 presidential election over anti-slavery Republican candidate John Fremont, Millard Fillmore coming in a distant third.

Did Lincoln community Quakers have “audacity combined with weakness” resulting in madness? Their population was, indeed, numerically “weak” within Loudoun county and rest of Virginia. The U.S. Census for the year 1860 shows Quaker Friends in Loudon [Loudoun] County to have 4 churches [Meetings] with a total of 1,500 members. That equals approximately 10% of Loudoun County’s population at the time. The Virginia Quaker/Friends’ state wide population total in 1860 was 5,800. No Quaker would have considered their religious convictions a sign of weakness, but the Census does show them to be greatly out-numbered.

united states churches pre Civil War
U.S. 1860 federal census for the state of Virginia, with counties listed alphabetically. This census page counts membership of religious denominations. Loudon [Loudoun] is shown at the bottom of the right hand side Counties column. Friends is upper center of the page. Courtesy U.S. Census Bureau

Loudoun County had approximately 24% of the Quakers living in the entire state of Virginia.

list of churches and counties from U.S. census bureau
U.S. 1860 Census for the state of Virginia, divided by Counties. Courtesy of U.S. Census Bureau

Quaker pacifism and anti-slavery beliefs left the sect open to suspicion and hostility from main stream Southern neighbors. When Civil War broke out on April 14, 1861, Quaker failure to officially support the Confederacy added to Goose Creek’s (not yet named “Lincoln”) isolationism.

In September, 1861, Goose Creek Meeting minutes addressed the worsening national conflict. A transcript of the carefully worded position on the war is below the image.

Goose Creek Meeting minutes 9 month 1861, addressing the topic of war. Courtesy ancestry.com
Continuing page of Goose Creek Meeting minutes addressing the war. Courtesy ancestry.com

9 Month 1861

“At Goose Creek Monthly Meeting, held the 10th of 9th mo, 1861, the representatives were present, except Eli J. Hoge for whose absence a satisfactory reason was given….

[bottom paragraph] “The subject of making a statement of our principles, in regard to the unhappy condition of our country, in order to correct any misapprehension that may exist respecting our views, being brought before the meeting, it was concluded to issue the following declaration, which was entered with by women friends and the clerk was directed to sign the same on behalf of the meeting, and Samuel M. Janney, Jesse Hoge, and Elisha Janney were appointed to lay the subject before Fairfax Monthly Meeting in order that, that meeting, may have an opportunity of acting on the same: to wit:

“1st The religious society of Friends, from the time of its rise, to the present date (a period of more than two hundred years) has always borne a testimony against war; its members abstaining from every kind of military service, and patiently suffering the penalties of the law for declining the same. This testimony we believe is in accordance with the example and precepts of Christ, and particularly his sermon on the mount.

“2nd In as much as a state of war now unhappily exists in this country, we deem it our religious duty to take no part in it; and to abstain from every act that would give aid in its prosecution.

“3rd Although laws might be passed, with which our principles and clear sense of religious duty would forbid our active compliance even though there was connected therewith the heaviest penalty; yet the religion we profess, and as we conceive, the true spirit of Christianity, forbid our doing any act in opposition to the laws of the government under which [we] live. In all cases, not obviously and exclusively between ourselves and our Maker, we believe it to be our solemn duty, faithfully to comply with the laws of the land, or remain entirely passive under them, suffering all penalties.” Then Concluded

19th century quakers standing outside meetinghouse
Goose Creek Meeting, Lincoln, Virginia photo from private collection

Much, even most, about the lives of Quakers in Lincoln, Virginia was routine and predictable. But in spite of that, these Quakers were a memorable group. Their lives were filled with steadfast, moral certainty amidst a growing drama of violence that led ultimately to war. Individual Quakers in the village of Lincoln exhibited acts of kindness and extreme courage, two characteristics that, under the circumstances of time and place, were extraordinary.

2nd century Greek georgrapher Pausanias lived many centuries before George Fox founded the Quaker faith in 1647. There is no way to know if the Greek would have considered Lincoln Quakers’ actions a sign of “Audacity combined with weakness should be called madness.” However, their September 1861 principles stake out a position to which, if implying “madness,” they would have said: so be it.

4 comments on “Goose Creek quakers: the audacity of peace and social justice

  1. Do you know if John Brown was in anyway connected to these Quakers?


    • hello, dcmori, I cannot find any connection with the Goose Creek meeting Quakers and John Brown. Since Quakers were pacifist, as you know, they wouldn’t have approved of Brown’s methods of overthrowing slavery. However, anti-slavery Quakers, such as Lucretia Mott, gave support and a place to stay to Brown’s wife, Mary Ann Day, during Brown’s incarceration and trial.
      I’ll keep looking amongst the 19th century Lincoln, VA Quakers for private letters that might express an opinion about John Brown, Lee

      Liked by 1 person

      • Thank you for your interesting response. I am immersed in James McBride’s “The Good Lord Bird” about John Brown and certainly should have thought of the pacifist angle, which Brown definitely was not. Lucretia Mott may well appear in this novel, which is packed with actual people and places throughout Brown’s crusade, and I look forward to learning more about her, either way.


  2. I’ve heard of the Good Lord Bird, and now you’ve made me want to read it! Another good John Brown book is Midnight Rising by Tony Horwitz (I think that is how his name is spelled.)


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: